Thigpen, C.H. & Cleckley, H. (1954)

A case of multiple personality. Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 49, 135-51

Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) is one of the most fascinating and controversial psychological conditions.  It is not to be confused with schizophrenia as sufferers do not experience the emotional and cognitive disturbances typical of schizophrenia.  Although the term schizophrenia means, literally, ‘split-mind’, this refers to the loss of unity between psychological functions. Multiple Personality Disorder is defined as a ‘dissociative disorder in which two or more distinct personalities co-exist within the same individual’. Individually each personalities may be fully integrated and have distinct memories, behaviour patterns, social relationships and cognitive functioning. There is a long running debate over whether such a condition actually exists.

Why did Eve White (not her real name) first go to a therapist?

Extract: After a discussion of the mysterious letter which Eve White denied having sent, she suddenly put her hands to her head as if in pain.  After a moment of silence her hands dropped, and the therapist observed a ‘quick, reckless smile’.  In a bright voice she said ‘Hi there, Doc!’. Eve White had changed into a confident and relaxed person. She crossed her legs and the therapist ‘noted from the corner of his awareness something distinctly attractive about them, and also this was the first time he had received such an impression’.

How does the therapist interpret this observation?

Suggest one other interpretation for this observation.

The therapist concluded that Eve was suffering from Multiple Personality Disorder. Explain the difference between ‘multiple personality disorder’ and ‘having different sides to your personality’.

What did the therapist discover about the ‘histories’ of Eve White and Eve Black?

Outline the differences identified between the personalities of Eve White and Eve Black.

The authors of the article suggest that the psychological tests given to Eve provide evidence for the idea that Eve White was suffering from Multiple Personality Disorder. Outline the differences between the two personalities identified by these tests:

TEST

Eve White

Eve Black

IQ

   

MEMORY

   

RORSCHACH

   

Who was Jane?

What did the electroencephalogram (EEG) suggest about the personalities of Eve White, Eve Black and Jane?

The article suggests that there is an ethical (or moral) dilemma raised by the treatment of this case. Explain what this is.

Finally, what problems with the case study method does this study highlight?